Rent or Buy

Two people, the same flat, the same years: one buys, one rents and invests the difference. Who ends up richer?

Your numbers

Buying

$
What the home costs to buy.
$
Fees and taxes paid on top of the price when you buy; the renter invests this instead.
%
The part of the price paid from your own money.
%
The mortgage’s yearly interest rate.
How long the mortgage runs; once it’s paid off the buyer only has ownership costs.
Ownership costs
$
A monthly fee to the building or association for shared upkeep.
%
$
A yearly tax as a % of the home’s value.
A fixed yearly tax on owning the home.
$
Home insurance the owner pays each year.
%
Repairs and upkeep inside the home, as a % of its value each year.

Renting

$
Rent for the same home today.
%
How much rent rises each year; fixed ownership costs rise at the same rate.

Markets & period

%
How much the home’s value rises each year.
%
The yearly return on money either person invests.
%
Agent fees and costs to sell, as a % of the value; taken off the buyer’s net worth.
yr
How long you’d stay; 1 to 30 years.

After 10 years

Buyer’s net worth
–
The home’s value minus the loan left and selling costs, plus anything the buyer invested.
Renter’s net worth
–
Everything the renter invested — the down payment and buying costs plus monthly savings — with its returns.
Buyer minus renter
–
Positive means buying leaves you better off; negative means renting does.
Break-even year
–
The year from which the buyer is ahead and stays ahead to the end of the period.

What if prices grow differently?

The buyer-minus-renter difference at four price growth rates, with everything else as you entered it.

Price growthBuyer’s net worthRenter’s net worthBuyer minus renter
The row closest to your price growth is in bold.

Net worth year by year

Each person’s net worth at the end of every year; where the lines cross, the other person takes the lead.

Buyer Renter

Yearly table

The numbers behind the chart, at the end of each year (year 0 is the day you buy).

YearBuyer pays / moRent / moHome equityBuyer investedBuyer net worthRenter net worthBuyer minus renter
  • Buyer pays / mo: the mortgage payment plus ownership costs that year.
  • Rent / mo: the renter’s rent that year.
  • Home equity: the home’s value minus the loan left and minus selling costs — what selling would leave you.
  • Buyer invested: the buyer’s savings, built up in months when renting would have cost more.
  • Buyer net worth: home equity plus the buyer’s investments.
  • Renter net worth: the renter’s investments, started with the down payment and buying costs.
  • Buyer minus renter: how far the buyer is ahead (positive) or behind (negative).

Each month, whoever pays less invests the difference. All figures are before tax: taxes on investment gains and on selling a home depend on your country (in Czechia, both can become tax-free after certain holding periods).